Epilogue (AKA Part 4)

This is the fourth (and,I hope, final) thing I will write about this.  Read Part 1, Part 2, and Part 3 to get the whole story.

Were there warning signs with The Pilot? Sure. But it’s not like I ignored them. I confronted him directly any time I thought something seemed odd. And he lied, every time. I think of other things he said, things he did, while we were together, and I now see every last thing as a lie, whether it was or wasn’t.

  • When he said he loved me, he lied.
  • When he kissed me, he lied.
  • When he said he was sitting in a crash pad in Philly, on call, he lied.
  • When he said he was going to visit his parents, he lied.
  • When I woke with a headache and got up so as not to disturb him, and he followed me into the living room and sat with me on the couch, saying he couldn’t sleep without me, he lied.
  • When he buried his nose in my hair and (I thought) unconsciously inhaled my scent, he lied.
  • When he held and kissed my hand, he lied.
  • When he snuggled up next to me at night and told me how much he loved my bed, how much he missed it when he was gone, missed me when he was gone, he lied.

The thing I’m constantly wondering about is, does he feel any guilt about what he’s done to me, to her? Did he feel any guilt when he was actually in a relationship with both of us? And I keep coming up with the same answer – NO. And that really freaks me out, because that would make him a psychopath.

Think I’m being a bit extreme? Consider the description in Wikipedia: 

The prototypical psychopath has deficits or deviances in several areas: interpersonal relationships, emotion, and self-control. Psychopaths gain satisfaction through antisocial behavior, and do not experience shame, guilt, or remorse for their actions. Psychopaths lack a sense of guilt or remorse for any harm they may have caused others, instead rationalizing the behavior, blaming someone else, or denying it outright…. All of this belies their tendency to make a good, likable first impression. Psychopaths have a superficial charm about them, enabled by a willingness to say anything without concern for accuracy or truth…. Psychopaths also have a markedly distorted sense of the potential consequences of their actions, not only for others, but also for themselves. They do not, for example, deeply recognize the risk of being caught, disbelieved or injured as a result of their behaviour.


The Anger

I’m really having to fight the urge to be petty. You know how they say never to break up with a songwriter, because they will have the last word? Well, the same could be said for a blogger. I’ve already researched the defamation and libel laws. ( “To prove libel, which is the same thing as written defamation, the plaintiff has to prove that the blogger published a false statement of fact …” – IOW, if it’s true, I can’t be sued for libel or defamation.) I’ve thought about posting his full name, DOB, what company he flies for, etc, so that anyone in the future who searches his name (future girlfriends, maybe?) will know. I’d love to let his mother know what kind of son she raised, let his sister know what kind of man he is, let his aunt know that her husband isn’t the only one in the family to cheat. I’m afraid that one day, I won’t be able to stop myself from doing those things.

I am so freaking mad at him, at what he’s done. I’m pissed that he lied. I’m pissed that I was fooled by him. I’m pissed that I’ve wasted a year and a half of my life loving a man that doesn’t exist. I’m pissed that his friends must think he’s such a stud, a girl in each city, and were high-fiving him behind my back the whole time. I’m pissed that I had unprotected sex with him, almost from the beginning, because I thought we were in a monogamous relationship, I’m pissed that he risked my health in that way.

And, yeah, I’m mad at myself, too. I’m mad that I believed him. That I didn’t sometimes push harder. I’m mad that I’m an easy-going person, that I respected him enough to allow his excuse of “I’m a private person” to dissuade me from posting more stuff online, on Facebook, where he could be found out sooner.

It makes me so mad, because things were coming to a head, anyway. I was determined to have a serious conversation about the state of our relationship, but I wanted to get through the holidays first.


I agree with It Never Rains In Seattle, that he probably cut and ran when he found out that the other woman had emailed me. I think she probably confronted him, and he probably lied to her and said I was just a friend, maybe a friend who had “imagined” a relationship with him, and then he cut me out completely, maybe at her request. It kills me that he essentially snuck into my house while I wasn’t there to drop off my house key, and didn’t bother to even leave a note. Not even a simple post it note with “I’m sorry” on it, so at least I wouldn’t wonder and worry like I did. Heck, even Berger left Carrie a post it note.  (And, as a side note, I like what I found on this website:  “Break up in person! This cannot be stressed enough… have the courtesy to say goodbye face to face…. Use integrity and be honest as to why you are leaving…. Both parties will have some closure….”)

I’m big on closure. If I don’t have closure, I will continue thinking about it, breaking it apart, studying it, trying to figure it out. It’s killing me that I don’t have closure. I want to know why he decided to have a relationship with two women. Was he not satisfied with one, and if so, which one? Did we offer different things? Did he honestly fall in love with both of us and wasn’t able to decide which one to keep? Or was it simply an ego trip, to see if he could get away with it?

I still wish I could talk to The Pilot one last time. I would love an apology, an explanation. I know that’s wishful thinking, but what can I say, I’m an optimist at heart. I simply can’t understand how you can carry on two relationships, the way he did. How you can love someone, and do this to them. And I’m not just talking about me – I’m talking about her, too. If he loved her, how could he do this? If he loved me, how could he do this? It’s simply beyond my capacity of understanding.


The Hurt

Ever been picked last for the baseball team?

This is why the women on The Bachelor cry, even when they are eliminated on the first episode. It makes you feel like you’re not good enough.

Is she prettier than me? Smarter than me? Thinner? Funnier? Nicer? A better person?

I know this is stupid, and that I am an amazing, beautiful, intelligent woman. But that doesn’t stop the questions. Why did he pick her over me? Was it because he was dating her before me? Was it because he loved her more?

I’ve been telling myself that it’s because he knew, if he picked me and I found out, he wouldn’t have me anyway, but he still had a chance at keeping her. Because once I found out it would have been over. I’ve always wondered if I would stay with a man who cheated on me, but in the scenario I’ve always imagined, it’s a one-time thing. This was so much worse.


The man I was in love with didn’t exist. I had an imaginary boyfriend.

Honestly, I hate to say it, but it would be easier to handle if he had died. And, actually, it would really be almost accurate to say he had committed suicide. He, the him I knew, ceased to exist.


The Worry

I don’t believe trust should be earned, I believe it should be given. I don’t think you can have a good relationship without trust already being a part of it. I still believe that, but I’m going to have a hard time operating that way in the future. How can I ever believe anything any future man I date says to me? I really worry about this. I’m going to constantly be questioning what he says, my own instincts, wondering if he’s lying to me.

I don’t lie. Of course that’s not true – I say “I’m fine” when asked how I am, because nobody really wants the truth. But I don’t really lie. I think that, because I don’t, I don’t know how to recognize lying in others.

Will I ever be able to trust again? To not wonder if someone is telling the truth when they have a “business dinner” or “have to stay late at the office.” Or the lovely, “She’s just a friend.” I’m terrified that this will ruin any future relationship I have. That me not trusting the man I am with will drive him away.

How do you learn to trust again?

10 responses to “Epilogue (AKA Part 4)

  1. I think you should post his name, and any other info you think the world should know. He’s not going to sue you, because that would mean he would have to come out and tell everyone he is seeing about you. I promise, he doesn’t want to do that. You are letting him have too much power. Take it back.

  2. I’ll be sending you a private note about this, but in the meantime…

    Do not post his name out of a sense of revenge. That will diminish you, in the long run. You do not want to be that person. Spite will only hurt you… and you are hurt enough, as it is.

    But, well… DO post his name to protect the other women out there who are going to be hurt by him. And there will be others. THERE WILL BE OTHERS. Post his name. Post the cities you know he spends the most time in. You can’t do anything to fix him — psychopaths and sociopaths are not fixable. But you can warn away at least some of his potential, future victims. Do so calmly, without resorting to hyperbole or outrage.

    I looked over your site, having done a search on the phrase “The Pilot”. Wow, were there a lot of strange incidents all over the place. His not taking down his match.com profile, etc., etc. The guy is a piece of work. He is most definitely a sociopath and/or psychopath. And I question the integrity of his friends.

    Hang in there. You *are* an amazing, beautiful, intelligent woman. (At least, from what I can tell on your blog!) And not all men are sociopaths. Really.

    More on that later, too….

  3. I agree 100% with itneverrainsinseattle!

    You are beautiful and intelligent, and damned articulate too! He probably chose this other woman over you for precisely THAT reason alone. No smart woman would EVER put up with him after finding out the truth about him… If he has chosen her, then she is not the winner… She is the loser.

    If she is stupid enough to stay with him after this then she is accepting that she is with a man who would deliberately deceive her. She is accepting that he will never respect her or be trustworthy, because he has been allowed to get away with actually having another ‘meaningful’ relationship with another woman behind her back!

    After a year and a half, he KNOWS that you would not have allowed him to get away with this. It was attack as a form of defence… Psychopaths and sociopaths (and I suspect he may have a condition called ‘duping delight’) are also extremely narcissistic, and he was attempting to cut his losses by protecting his inflated ego… He knew that you would not be able to accept this and still continue to have a relationship with him… He would not have coped with the rejection.

    Knowing this will hopefully help you to move on. My friend went through something very similar to this. I would like you to have a look at her blog (she is just starting to write in depth about how her fiance lived a double life behind her back for over 5 years!) She has his son, and has not heard from him since she found out the truth!

    Her man IS a psychopath and he too is worried about how she will cope with trusting men in future relationships…


    Just thank your lucky stars that you didn’t find out in 3 years time… I know it’s not much consolation, but try to chalk it down to experience and move forward. I am disappointed that the other woman did not give you the closure that SHE had the audacity to ask you for! You at least have had empathy with her…

    Perhaps she deserves him after all? One thing is for sure… YOU DESERVE BETTER!

    • delightfuleccentric

      I agree – I am the winner in this, and she is the loser. My head knows that…

      Wow – I will definitely check out your friend’s blog. I can’t imagine how a man could do that (cut and run) when there’s a child involved.

  4. Hey… I am posting from my phone, so cannot get you the link right now, but there is a post on my blog where people name and shame cheating pilots it’s called “Pilot’s who Cheat, and are then stupid enough to BRAG about it!”

    If you do decide to name and shame him, it’s one of the most searchable ways to do so on the net… There is also a site called ‘don’t date him girl’ that a lot of people use. My blog has over 180 comments to date on that post!

  5. Pingback: Which is better? « DelightfulEccentric

  6. Holy crap, you and I could be relationship twins. I found out my boyfriend of a year and a half was cheating on me as well, and it was on December 29 (although a couple of years ago). I have felt everything you’ve described, and although not as intensely, still feel it on occasion over 2 years later.

    • delightfuleccentric

      Darn – I keep hoping I’ll eventually get to indifference, but I just feel like the betrayal was too deep to EVER get there.

  7. Pingback: I wish he HAD been imaginary « DelightfulEccentric